SpikeTheLobsterProofing And Editing
March 11th 2009 15:33
In the world of writing, there are some basic confusions that seem to propagate with time, distance, language barriers and whether or not it's Tuesday. One of these is the responsibilities of two different people who read a nearly-finished piece of work: the editor and the proofreader. Many people - including those posting freelance jobs on various sites - believe they are the same role under two different names. They're not.
An editor (or copy-editor) is the person with the harder job. Their role is to take a piece of text - an article, a story, a book or whatever - and transform it into something that flows smoothly. They look at the bigger picture, trying to determine whether the author's point is well-expressed or if a reader would understand it better were it formulated differently. The editors of the world are the true wordsmiths: they tear a piece of writing down to its component ideas and rebuild it, piece by piece, until it feels right. They will rewrite or remove some of the content and work very closely with the original authors.
A proofreader usually steps in at the last stage, just before publishing. Their job is not to determine whether the paragraphs are in the right order or whether the author's intention is one thing or another. They are correctors: their role consists of going over every letter of every word, every punctuation mark and every conjugated verb to hammer out every single error that remains in the text - even those missed by the editor. They are the geeky technicians, the "grammar Nazis" who will argue whether that colon should be a period or not.
The editor usually sees the work before the proofreader, and often sees it in a native state: that is, unformatted for the final presentation. The proofreader generally checks the work after it has been formatted and prepared for publication, so their job also entails verifying alignment, page breaks, columns and other layout details.
Both roles are expected to correct many of the basic problems, such as grammar, punctuation, spelling, subject-verb agreements, hyphens, capitalisation, abbreviations and any obvious mistakes, such as a character's name changing part-way through a story.
In some cases, there is an additional overlap of the two roles. Proofreaders are frequently expected to spot bad writing and bring it to the attention of their employer or the author. They are not generally expected to rewrite the content, though, unless specifically requested - this is because such activity would be [well-spotted, Zabeena!] stepping on the editor's toes!
In the job market, be it online or bricks-and-mortar, it is always worth checking exactly where the boundaries of the role lie before committing yourself to the task. And make sure your pay reflects your efforts.
| 97 |
| Vote |
Add To: 
subscribe to this blog
Comment by Mistersmith
MRS SMITH
READ THIS
SISTERS IN CRIME
Teresa here!
I was confused about this too until it was explained to me but I was told that the proofreader is the absolute final stage before printing and the chief purpose of proofreading is to make sure that the copy is going to transfer properly to the printed page - taking into account page numbers to ensure chapters beginning on right hand, etc Presumably online publishing is a bit diffferent. Anyway, you seem to know quite a bit. What is your background? (you may have said already, but I missed it).
Comment by Anonymous
there is a 'be' missing in your penulltimate paragraph.
wbr
Zabeena
Comment by Spike 2
Wordophilia
Qwerk
Peanut Butter
When I was editing/proofing at wargamer.com, they kept to the magazine style, though: the editor edited, the proofer looked at the content on the actual web pages before they went live - to check links, format, numbering and so on as well as a final run over the text.
Zabeena: It's always on the posts about editing and being 100% perfect that I miss a word. Sigh. I'll edit that, thank you!
Comment by James Rickard
unlucky_ fishermen.com
Angling Fish
Check this out...
Comment by James Rickard
unlucky_ fishermen.com
Angling Fish
Check this out...
Comment by Spike 2
Wordophilia
Qwerk
Peanut Butter
It reminds me of an old 'drunk driving' sign. It read like this:
SEE WHAT'S WRONG
THIS WITH SIGN
YOU SHOULDN'T BE DRIVING
Brilliant. And yes, it took me about five minutes to spot it, even though I wasn't drunk!!
Comment by Janet Collins
Acceptable Etiquette
The Social Critic
Janet Collins Blog
Comment by Mistersmith
MRS SMITH
READ THIS
SISTERS IN CRIME
If my computer is going really slow, I include another activity - like shaving my legs.
Comment by Spike 2
Wordophilia
Qwerk
Peanut Butter
Comment by Mistersmith
MRS SMITH
READ THIS
SISTERS IN CRIME
Chris could use this on his bloggercises: How the order of words can dramatically alter the meaning.